City operations facility · 689 lines
Feeders carried, switches not
The takeoff carried the generator and switchboard feeders to a 600A bypass-isolation ATS and a 100A life-safety ATS, but neither switch.
Makeoff data report · November 2026
What 97 Makeoff findings show about the scope between the transfer switch quote and the takeoff, and a 9-point transfer switch takeoff checklist to catch it.
Source: Makeoff production database · 49 projects, 22 electrical contractors · Apr 1 – Nov 11, 2026
Most electrical estimators don't take off transfer switches on the first pass. The switches ride on the switchgear or generator quote, and labor is built off that quote. So a takeoff with no automatic transfer switch (ATS) line is normal. The risk is scope that sits on no quote and never reaches the labor build-up. The transfer switch takeoff checklist at the end of this paper lists what to confirm on a quote-first bid.
Between April 1 and November 11, 2026, Makeoff raised 97 unique missed-scope findings tied to Section 26 36 00, Transfer Switches. They span 49 projects from 22 electrical contractors and exclude existing and owner-furnished equipment. Sixty-five flagged a missing transfer switch; this paper treats those as the quote-first workflow at work, not as misses. That leaves 32 findings.
Eleven findings named a fire pump controller with an integral transfer switch, six on working takeoffs. The controller can be furnished under fire protection or electrical, and the documents often don't say which.
Thirteen findings covered normal, emergency and load feeders, control raceway and seismic bracing at the switch. No quote carries them, and they total about $169K by Makeoff's estimate.
Separately, on the 32 takeoff lines where contractors did carry a transfer switch, labor ran a median 35 hours per switch, with the middle half between 14 and 56 hours. Seven carried no labor on the line.
In a separate test on nine projects, Makeoff listed all 16 transfer switches the estimators priced and none they did not.
A transfer switch reaches the bid through a quote. The work around it reaches the bid only if someone counts it.
First-pass takeoff. The estimator takes off feeders, panels and branch work. Transfer switches are left for the gear quote.
Switchgear or generator quote. The ATS or manual transfer switch (MTS), sometimes with bypass isolation, annunciators and startup. Which vendor carries it varies by job.
Labor built off the quote. Labor to set and terminate each switch, priced from the quote's equipment list.
So this paper treats a missing transfer switch as expected, not as a miss. That is an assumption about typical workflow, not something Makeoff observed job by job. Here is where each piece of transfer switch scope usually lands:
| Scope | Usually carried on | Risk in a quote-first bid |
|---|---|---|
| Transfer switch (ATS, MTS, bypass isolation) | Switchgear or generator quote | Low, once one quote clearly has it |
| Fire pump controller with transfer switch | Fire protection or electrical, per the specs | Each trade can assume the other has it |
| Remote annunciator, startup and testing | Switch or generator quote | Options vary by quote; verify against the spec |
| Normal, emergency and load feeders | Takeoff | Skipped when the switch is skipped on the first pass |
| Control raceway and wiring | Takeoff | The quote supplies terminals, not wiring |
| Anchorage, bracing and pads | Takeoff | Buried in specs and details |
| Fire pump feeder and disconnect | Takeoff | Special routing and protection rules under NEC Article 695 |
Set aside as expected · 65
Transfer switches
Assumed quoted, with labor built off the quote
Counted as findings · 32
Installation and connection
Feeders to and from the switch, control raceway, anchorage and bracing
Fire pump controllers
Controllers with an integral transfer switch
Annunciators and testing
Remote annunciators, startup and testing
Other
Findings with no mapped spec section
Setting aside the 65 transfer switch findings leaves 32. Three in four of those are fire pump controllers or installation and connection scope.
On working takeoffs, 13 findings remain after the switches: 6 fire pump controllers, 4 installation items, 2 annunciator or testing items, and 1 unmapped spec section. Across all findings, fire pump controllers carry about $544K of estimated value and installation findings about $169K.
Transfer switch findings are uncommon: under 1% of the 11,175 missing-item findings Makeoff raised for customers in the window. For what estimators miss across all scope, see our Where Mistakes Hide report.
A finding is only useful if it is right. Makeoff tested its read of the drawings against what estimators priced. On transfer switches it did not miss one or invent one.
In September and October 2026, Makeoff scored its gear list, the equipment it reads from the drawings, against estimators' priced takeoffs on 53 projects. Nine of them had transfer switches. Estimators priced 16 transfer switches, automatic and manual. Makeoff listed all 16 and no others: 100% recall and 100% precision.
The result is clean because a transfer switch is always named. Every one carried a tag on the one-line, such as ATS-1, ATS-LS or MTS-GEN, or a label the estimator repeated word for word.
The test scored the switches themselves. Fire pump controllers, feeders, control raceway and anchorage were not scored, and ratings were weaker: the export carried an amperage for five of 13 switches in the October batch.
When Makeoff says the drawings call for a transfer switch and the takeoff has no line for it, the switch is on the drawings. Contractors who acted on a finding mostly agreed: of 13 decisions, they added the scope on 3, reviewed 7 and ignored 3.
Sixty-five findings flagged a transfer switch with no takeoff line, 44 of them from drawing reviews before any takeoff was loaded. In a quote-first bid, that is what the first pass should look like.
On working takeoffs, the pattern shows up directly.
City operations facility · 689 lines
The takeoff carried the generator and switchboard feeders to a 600A bypass-isolation ATS and a 100A life-safety ATS, but neither switch.
College campus · 213 lines
The largest finding, a 3,000A service-entrance-rated manual transfer switch, sat on a takeoff with no switchboards, panels or transformers.
Industrial plant · 114 lines
The takeoff carried removal of the existing ATS, but not the new 1,200A service-entrance-rated switch. The contractor ignored the finding.
Manufacturing plant · 536 lines
A contractor-supplied ATS had no line. The contractor reviewed it and added: "Tough bc we can't see this."
That last note is the catch in a quote-first bid. When the switch lives on a quote the takeoff can't see, nobody can confirm it is there until the quotes are leveled.
Contractors carried 32 transfer switch lines priced at $5,000 or more per switch on customer takeoffs in Makeoff. Labor ran a median 35 hours per switch, about 13% of the line's value, with the middle half between 14 and 56 hours. Seven of the 32 lines carried no labor on the line, though it may sit elsewhere in the takeoff. The work around the switch is where the checklist below applies.
Eleven findings named a fire pump controller with an integral transfer switch. The controller is often furnished under fire protection and fed by the EC, but the electrical one-line shows it either way.
Six were raised on working takeoffs, three of them over 1,400 lines.
Student housing, two phases · 1,530 and 1,545 lines
A service-entrance-rated fire pump controller and ATS for a 40 HP, 480V pump, plus a dedicated meter and disconnect ahead of the main. The contractor reviewed one of the two.
Medical research and manufacturing · 1,414 lines
A mist-system fire pump controller with integral ATS on the standby one-line.
Multifamily · 472 lines
A fire pump ATS and the feeder path from the service tap to a fire pump switch. The documents don't say who furnishes the controller.
Public health laboratory · 306 lines
One fire pump controller with power transfer switch in the fire pump room.
Mixed-use multifamily · 42 lines
A 125 HP pump with its controller and transfer switch, a 600A manual transfer switch, and alarms for disconnect open and not in automatic.
The feeder, disconnect and alarm wiring around the controller belong in the takeoff even when the controller is someone else's.
Fire pump controller
Its integral transfer switch
The dedicated fire pump feeder
Its disconnect
Alarm wiring for disconnect open and not in automatic
Thirteen findings named labor and material that no switch quote carries: feeders to and from the switch, control raceway, and anchorage.
They total about $169K across the 12 with an estimate. And they live on the one-line, in notes and in the specs, not on the switch's equipment list.
Student housing · 1,545 lines
The one-line shows a 350A feed to the fire pump controller and ATS. A note requires a concrete-encased feeder per CEC 695.6 outside the electrical and fire pump rooms. Est. $40K; reviewed.
College campus · 213 lines
The spec requires floor-standing equipment anchored and braced to structure. The 3,000A manual transfer switch had neither. Est. $6K.
Retail store · 17 lines
Two 100A runs in 1-1/4-inch conduit, to the switch and on to a new panel. The takeoff had the conductors but no conduit. The switch itself was owner-provided; the feeders are still EC work. Est. $2.5K; reviewed.
Manufacturing plant · 46 lines
Three 2-inch and two 1-inch Schedule 40 RNC runs to GEN-1 and manual transfer switch MTS-201 were missing.
Drawing reviews show the full pattern: each ATS brings three feeders. At one medical office, ATS-LS1 had a 100A normal feeder from the main switchboard, a 100A emergency feeder from the standby switchboard, and a 100A load feeder to the life-safety panel.
Others named generator-to-ATS feeders, the feeder from an ATS to an airport's emergency panel, and special-circuit feeds to an ATS, a UL 924 inverter and a manual transfer switch.
Contractors recorded a decision on 13 of the 97 findings.
| Outcome | Findings | What they were |
|---|---|---|
| Completed | 3 | A 125A, a 300A and a 400A ATS, each added from a drawing review |
| Reviewed | 7 | Three switches (one "prob included in distribution package"), a fire pump controller, three feeder findings |
| Ignored | 3 | A 1,200A replacement ATS, a 200A emergency ATS, a fire pump controller |
| Open | 84 | No decision recorded in Makeoff, which does not mean the finding was wrong |
The three completed findings show that not every shop works quote-first. Two of the three ignored were switches on working takeoffs, which fits the quote-first pattern. For how one estimating group acted on Makeoff findings over eight weeks of live bids, read five scope misses caught on live competitive bids.
When the switchgear or generator quote comes in and you build its labor, check each item against the quotes and the takeoff. Every item came up in this data set except housekeeping pads.
Want a second set of eyes on your next transfer switch job?
Send us a bid you already priced, and Makeoff will flag the scope the takeoff doesn't carry.
Confirm which quote or trade carries each transfer switch on the one-line, any fire pump controller with a transfer switch, and the remote annunciators, startup and testing. Then put the work around the switches in the takeoff: labor to set and terminate each switch; normal, emergency and load feeders; generator-to-ATS feeders and control raceway; the fire pump feeder, its disconnect and alarm wiring; and seismic anchorage and bracing for floor-standing switches.
The work that connects the switch to the building: normal, emergency and load feeders, control raceway and wiring, and anchorage and bracing. No quote carries them, so they belong in the takeoff.
Usually. In a quote-first bid the ATS or MTS rides on the switchgear or generator quote, sometimes with bypass isolation, annunciators and startup. Which vendor carries it varies by job, so confirm every switch on the one-line against a quote.
It depends on the specs. The controller is often furnished under fire protection and fed by the electrical contractor, but the electrical one-line shows it either way. Whoever furnishes it, the electrical contractor usually carries the dedicated feeder, its disconnect and the alarm wiring.
On 32 transfer switch lines priced at $5,000 or more per switch on customer takeoffs in Makeoff, labor ran a median 35 hours per switch, with the middle half between 14 and 56 hours. That is labor on the switch line only. Feeders, control raceway and anchorage are separate.
Section 26 36 00, Transfer Switches, is the MasterFormat specification section for transfer switches, in Division 26, Electrical. Much of the work that connects a switch to the building is not on the switch's equipment list. It sits on the one-line and in drawing notes, schedules and other spec sections.
This paper covers missing-item findings tied to Section 26 36 00, Transfer Switches, and the work that connects a switch to the building.
Source: Makeoff production database, queried November 11, 2026. Validity testing: Makeoff Takeoff Agreement Benchmark: Transfer Switches, November 2, 2026.
Makeoff reviews electrical bids against the drawings and specs and flags scope the takeoff doesn't carry, like the transfer switch feeders and fire pump scope in this paper. To see what it flags on one of your bids, visit makeoff.com.
Will Zacher is the CEO of Makeoff.