Electrical Estimating Software: Product Review

IEC Atlanta & Georgia Chapters: Makeoff AI for Estimating

Round‑table Panel:
Brad Christian – Senior Estimator, ECI (diverse commercial portfolio; three‑person estimating team), IEC Estimating Instructor
Michael Gunter – 27‑year IEC instructor & former estimating director (scaled revenue from $300 K → $20 M), IEC Estimating Instructor
Todd Hawkins – Vice President Education & Membership Development, IEC Atlanta
Snapshot

The grind: Incomplete drawings, 1,000‑page spec books, and manual alternates keep commercial estimators late at the office.
Makeoff’s promise:
Parse the plans, reveal the pricey omissions, match every line to live vendor pricing, then build cost‑effective alternates in seconds.
Big win:
Hours shaved between take‑off and summary, tighter pricing on fast‑turn tenant‑improvement (TI), mixed‑use, and light‑industrial bids. Find missed items fast.
Best fit:
Contractors bidding multiple commercial projects per week: office TI, mixed‑use, warehouses, retail refreshes, who live inside McCormick today.

Why Makeoff?

A week before this demo, Erin asked herself: “Surely AI should be doing something for me by now.” Paige connected her with Makeoff, whose promise isn’t to reinvent ConEst, it’s to pull all your bid docs together and make sense of it.Makeoff’s differentiator: it “thinks” through materials and notes, ranking what matters by financial severity and generating VE alternates on command.

The Challenge

Teams face mounting pressure when precision meets tight deadlines. As Mike puts it, "Miss one line in those specs and profit evaporates" – a reality that underscores how costly specification errors can be in competitive bidding environments.

The situation becomes even more problematic when value engineering alternates need complete rebuilding before bid day, destroying the momentum teams have worked hard to build.

While counting devices and materials might seem straightforward, the real time drain comes from calculating extensions and generating comprehensive summaries, tasks that continue to consume hours of valuable pre-bid time when every minute counts toward submission deadlines.

“Drawings are half‑finished; we end up taking the same job off three times.
Brad

What Was Demoed

Mockup

Bill of Materials Match & Live Pricing

• Drop CSV/Excel exports from McCormick.
• Auto‑match to multi‑vendor catalogs (Graybar, World, etc.).
• Labor defaults to NECA but global sliders let you dial rates for merit-shop work.
Mockup

Spec & Note Analysis

• Reads electrical plans/specs plus optional MEP/site PDFs.
• Flags items missing in the take‑off; ranked by cost impact (e.g., temporary power, owner‑furnished disconnects).
• Full note dump stays searchable for keywords like allowance or furnish & install.
Mockup

One-Click Value Engineering

• Pre‑built copper → aluminum feeder swap saved ~ $20 K on a demo warehouse TI.
• Chat‑prompt edits add devices or swap fixtures instantly.
• Road‑mapped presets: efficient lighting packages, PSF caps, LEED alternates.

Fast Start & Export

Five-minute ramp—no courses or long seminars. Exportable, itemized invoices (materials, labor, risk, tax, overhead, profit) for instant client-ready quotes.
• Special IEC Member Pricing
• Itemised quote: materials, labor, overhead, profit; downloads for GC submission.
MacBook mockup

Panel Verdict

Notes highlight the money traps.

VE generator eliminates conduit/labor guesswork.

Low cost & zero learning curve make it a practical add‑on for lean teams.

Improve: Supplier Number Lock

Lock quoted items so Value Engineering never overwrites supplier numbers.

Improve: Import Assemblies

Import custom McCormick assemblies (in development).

Improve: Quick Keyword Scan

Quick keyword search & broader MEP scanning on the roadmap.

Who Should Try It Now

Contractors Doing Many Bids

Contractors churning two‑to‑four bids a week for commercial TI, office, and retail build‑outs.

Design-build teams

Design‑build crews seeking fast “premium vs. lean” cost options for owners.

Mid-size shops

Mid‑size shops (4–30 electricians) where estimators double as PMs.

New Independents

New independents looking for an AI safety net while they master McCormick.

Ready to Try Makeoff Now?

Contact Todd at Todd.Hawkins@iecatlantaga.org or book a demo with Will Zacher.
Bring a recent CSV + PDFs and watch Makeoff spots lost profits, hidden costs in minutes.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
MacBook mockup